Creamy Tomato Basil Soup and Basil Grilled Cheese

Some things are worth it. Be it time, distance or price, some things are just worth the effort. This entry covers all the bases. Get comfortable. I have a lot to say…as does Ole.
cheese factory
While we were in California this year on a trip back to Martinelli, one of our favorite wineries, we were told about a great cheese shop outside of Santa Rosa. We followed the hand drawn map, found Llano Road and turned down the driveway that transitioned from blacktop to dirt, past the vines and bovines, past a pile of pumpkins and a very crooked tree to a small building by a barn. We found ourselves at Joe Matos Cheese Factory at closing time. Luckily, a loud alarm rings when you open the door alerting all in the surrounding mile that you are there in the drying room. It’s a good thing there are only fields and cows in that mile.

It didn’t take long for Mary Matos to appear from another room, and before we could even say a word, she’d cut off generous hunks of St. Jorges, the only variety the Matos produce, named for the island in the Azores from which they immigrated. The flavor is sort of like a mild Swiss except creamier and more delicious, maybe with some Havarti thrown in. A Google or two let’s us know that melting it is ideal.
St Jorge
If you find yourself in the area, be sure to swing over and pick some up. Note: the Matos take only cash, no plastic here – a fact that caused us to make a return trip the next day. After carefully packaging it for the return trip home, our chunk of St. Jorges met its final destination (2,064 miles from its origin), in the perfect grilled cheese sandwich. Yes, perfect.
cheese on board
All I added to the cheese and bread (aside from a large smear of butter on the whole grain bread) was a few basil leaves. This cheese can stand alone on a cracker, in a mac and cheese, between two slices of bread or just in the palm of your hand. And to make it a meal, what better than a steaming bowl of homemade tomato soup?
basil grilled cheese
Heat a bit of olive oil in a pan.
oil in pan
Toss in a few diced tomatoes and a bit of onion and let it cook down.
tomatoes and onions
It should get nice and juicy.
cooking tomatoes and onions
Towards the end we’ll add the garlic (to make sure it doesn’t burn).
add garlic
Then add crushed tomatoes, whether they come from a store-bought can or one you filled yourself at the end of the growing season. I also add a bit of water here because I felt like the mixture looked a little thicker than I’d personally like. Just a bit to help it simmer.
add more tomatoes
After the tomatoes have been simmering for 25 minutes or so, add fresh basil to the mix. I cut up the larger leaves, but I left the smaller ones for the hand blender. I just gave it a few pulses to take care of some of the larger tomato chunks and bring the soup together more. You could pour all the soup (slightly cooled) at this point into a blender and puree it into one even texture, or you could use a hand blender until your desired consistency is reached. Me? I don’t mind a few chunks, so a few pulses was all it took.
basil it in
Add a cup of cream to the soup and season it with kosher salt and pepper to your liking.
cream it
After another 5 or so minutes (to heat up the cream but not boil it), you’re ready to serve. This should be just enough time to finish up the grilled cheese.
At this point I realized that my light bulbs above the stove and the sink were burnt out, making for difficult lighting in the kitchen area. I then went to the table, but you can see that wasn’t much better. The overhead bubble light did nothing for the soup and sandwich.
Plus, I had limited space with one of my brother-in-laws and his four kids joining ours.
keeping it real
I went into the living room, but the darker colors and, again, overhead bubble lights were just not giving me anything. And I was starting to get hungry.
And the temptation and curiosity of how the cheese had fared during the melting process was too much. I wasn’t disappointed. The St. Jorge’s melted beautifully, and the basil complemented the nuttiness of the cheese and the whole thing together contrasted the creamy soup and made for a perfect dunking companion.
grilled cheese

Never miss a recipe! Have them delivered right to your RSS feed or to your inbox as an email!


  1. The soup and sandwich were excellent!!! I’m sure glad we showed up for supper. Will you make me some more?

  2. Thanks to you we also found the Matos Cheese Factory, met Mary, and purchased two huge chunks of their wonderful cheese. Of course we were too excited and started gobbling it while driving up the dirt road. We didn’t save enough for your soup and sandwich recipe. Next time!

  3. i’ve been on the hunt for a creamy tomato basil soup … i will be trying this recipe. thank you so much! AND i bookmarked the farm you mention. it’s just a drive for us and a quick weekend trip. so fun!
    .-= Christi´s last blog gavin =-.

  4. Love the soup and sandwich. I will be looking the Matos factory up when there next month. The picture of the melted cheese sandwich made me hungry. Thanks for the recipes.
    .-= Ken´s last blog ..Automatic Pasta Maker =-.

  5. Great post. Thanks for the info

  6. I made this soup several times and it was a huge hit each time! Thanks for sharing!!

  7. This soup is great, I have made it several times.

  8. Instead of water, i’ve used veggie broth and added diced zucchini. This soup also turns out to be a great sauce for chicken parmesan the next day. Thanks so much for the post. sorry about the previous post, my daughter (15months old) hit submit before i could finish 🙂

  9. Michelle says:

    Can this be made with fresh tomatoes, and if so how, because it really looks tastey

    • You can just substitute 28 ounces crushed fresh tomatoes for the canned. You’ll want to remove the skins if the texture bothers you, but essentially diced and smashed and simmered a bit.


  1. […] hoping 2011 sends us there. The St. Jorges grilled cheese and basil sandwiches are divine, and the tomato basil soup pairs perfectly with them. The most-viewed post on Food for My Family this year was for the […]

  2. […] I decided to make creamy tomato basil soup and garlic bread grilled cheese. I kindasorta followed this recipe from Food For My Family for the soup… I really only used it as a guide since I didn’t […]

  3. […] by Food For My Family Share this:Like this:LikeBe the first to like this […]

  4. […] Creamy Tomato Basil Soup from Food For My Family […]

  5. […] Virginia today and a craving for tomato soup hit me hard. I did a little pinning and stumbled upon this mouth-watering recipe at Food for my Family. It was her detailed photos of each step of the recipe that really sold me on […]

  6. Soup Season says:

    […] Creamy Tomato Basil Soup & Basil Grilled Cheese – Food for My Family […]

Speak Your Mind